Curly said:I have APSs in two strats, SSLs in two others
as stated, the APS if fat and warm in the neck. I like the little extra sustain - seems a little more touch responsive
UCSDBoy said:Maybe I'm in the extreme, but I use APSes in my strat and I'm never going to use anything else... =)
BachToRock said:I use the APS's with a Twangbanger in the Bridge... A2 is produces the best strat tones to my ear... nice & smooth
Stratcat said:I agree, it also has a nice Bell Tone as well.
Lewguitar said:I have to say that although I love the APS-2/Twangbanger combo I still prefer alnico 5 neck and middle pickups like the Surfers or SSL-1's. The tone of alnico 5 Strat pickups is classic: bright, bubbley, clear, lively, etc. It's the tone I hear when I listen to hendrix or SRV or Knopfler.
The APS-2/TB set up is killer...but it's a more "modern" sound. Thicker, chunkier, smoother and not as biting, bubbley and glassy as SSL-1's.
It's all good...and it's nice to have a choice. I just happen to have the vintage tone stuck in my head and that's what I want to hear from the neck and middle pickups when I play chords or double stop R&B stuff.
Guitar Toad said:Help me out here. Perhaps my ears are not well trained. But, when I think of the SSL-1 form what I've heard on the forum I think bright. But, Hendrix to me doesn't sound bright. but perhaps he uses the notch positions with a lot of disortion(gain,overdrive) that loses the brightness but gives him his classic tone? Or does he roll the tone control to remove the brightness?
Lewguitar said:Touch is everything! And you have to learn to shape the tone with BOTH hands.
Hendrix had a great touch. As did SRV. But Hendrix, especially, could sound annoyingly bright and thin at times in live performance.
The SSL-1 is a bright pickup...but it's still closer to what Hendrix or SRV or Buddy Guy or Knopfler used in thier Strats. Some guys scrape the strings and have a harsh attack with thier pick and overall touch on the guitar and as a result, they get a harsh tone...but I think those guys should learn to develop a nicer touch on thier guitars and learn to shape the tone with thier hands a little better, rather than looking for a pickup to correct what's really a deficiency in playing technique...unless you like that harsh edgey tone!
Buddy Guy seems to like it! And I do too - but only when Buddy does it. :laugh2:
Guitar Toad said:It would be cool to see Hendrix live!
Some have said that the APS are smoother with distortion. ARe the APS preferable when seeking a dirty tone? Or do the SSL/Surfers do just as well and we are really in the realm of preference.