Re: Best Constructed Tweed Strat Tele Guitar case?
As far as durability goes, fabric isn't as robust as vinyl, which is not as robust as molded, which is not as robust as the laminate that most of the ATA-rated cases used to be made of. My Anvils from the 70s are scarred but intact, and have taken hits that would have penetrated the surface of a molded case and perhaps destroyed a wood frame one.
I have one Journeyman case and like it. I don't think the outer burlap is any more durable than tweed fabric, but it's distinctive and I like the luxurious blue lining. Build quality is good, as is the hardware. It has a solid feel, with excellent interior padding and good fit.
I have a couple of the GFS cases too, including a tweed one. Unbeatable for the money and quite decent quality regardless, as some already have said. No trouble so far with the latches or hinges and interior padding is okay though not excellent. They have a selection of colors & patterns which changes periodically. One of my favorites is tan "ostrich" vinyl with green lining; that one is no longer offered. They have paisley now, which is kinda cool. And they ship fast.
The best tweed case I have is a G&G. Real quality, and a bit more expensive than the cheap ones but not outrageous, especially for a favorite instrument.
TKLs are super quality too. I have a number of those going back many years but I'm not sure they offer tweed these days.