Hence my reinforced suggestion of the Custom. It's not as high output as it might seem, and I'd also suggest that you get a push-pull pot to wire it in series/parallel. Parallel will lower its output and cut lows and mids, which may help if you want to play clean on the bridge pickup, or to give it a broader tonal palette under gain.
Check out the conditions for the 21-day exchange policy, since my best bet would be either the Custom or the Distortion, although the latter's mids will be way too aggressive for the styles you mentioned. I own both in mahogany body guitars, the Custom in a PRS SE Custom 24 and the Distortion on a Dean Old Skull V, and to my ears the Custom does Classic Rock/ Metal / Stoner better than the Distortion. Note that the Distortion name is as misleading as SD's EQs charts, though...
Everybody's ears are different, anyway.