Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

What p'ups did you try?

Inquiring minds would like to know. :cool2:

Suhr pickups. Easy to do a direct comparison because the DS pickups are exactly the same as the SS pickups, just with a double row of screws instead of the usual arrangement. I've tried the SSV and DSV neck, SSV and DSV bridge and SSV+ and DSV+ bridge and it all cases I've preferred the SS versions. They seems to have a sharper attack and more "attitude". I'm also one of those people who can hear a difference between covered and uncovered humbuckers (and prefers uncovered), for whatever it's worth. And also, I just like the look of screws and slugs much more than the double screw look :D
-
Austin
 
Last edited:
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

Perpetual Burn screw coil, PGn slug coil, A2.

There are only three Perpetual Burn p'ups for sale in Italy, all in Internet shops, so I doubt they're even here.

Frank, is the PB wound with AWG 42 or AWG 43 wire?

Inquiring minds would like to know. :cool2:
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

as others have said, its the attack of the double screw in the neck that i dont like. there is no edge to it so when playing fast runs the notes mush together
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

I'd say "no" to the double screw if only for aesthetic reasons. We can't pretend that looks don't matter if the pickup is to have broad appeal.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

I'm speaking about fillister screws not hex screws. The proposed form factor is double fillister. I'm not interested in what a pickup can be modified into, any pickup can be modified. To me a pickup that requires modification to be useful to me is worthless. Mods should be something you do cause you want to not cause you need to.

Man, you're on the wrong forum. :D

The hybro idea makes no sense if the pickup is to be a neck version of the 59C. It would be better paired with its own bridge pickup.

I think that was one of the things Kojak is pushing for. The Fuglybucker ended up being a set. I think he wants to come up with a neck pickup that would match the 59/C, and a new bridge pickup that would also work with the new neck pickup. (Since there's no neck pickup match for the Custom, people would often pair it with the 59 or Jazz, even though there's 59 sets and the JB/Jazz set.) For people that just want a new neck pickup, it works, and there's a new bridge pickup for people that may want to try that. Then there's a new set as well. Might interest more people that way.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

I like the idea of using hexes and fillister. I discovered that i can get a better balance between the wound and the plain strings by using all hexes for the wound and all fillisters for the plains.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

We could even do bass side hex and treble side fili too, or even the other way around. Maybe even harken back to the Z idea where we have 3 fili and 3 hex each side and,each coil has it reversed, similar to how the Wide Range works but that slugs and filisters. We can even let the Custom Shop decide which set of screws sounds the best or closest to the tone we are asking for.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

Frank, is the PB wound with AWG 42 or AWG 43 wire?
This would be "educated speculation"

Perpetual Burn development did not begin until after I'd left the company. So I am not speaking as a former employee confirming the spec, nor have I taken one apart as a consumer for measurement. Based on what I know about wire and bobbin size, you can not fit that amount of 42 regardless of the insulation thickness. I believe it's 43, like an underwound Custom coil, or overwound Demon coil. You can see in photos that it's not Plain Enamel. It has the color of a Poly wire. Some photos make it appear more reddish which can mean thicker build coating, but you can order the red tint or clear in single build or heavy build.

Point is, assuming the Perpetual Burn is not a hybrid (which has never been discussed as far as I know) you'd be getting a ~6k 43AWG Poly coil up against the fretboard and a good PAF coil (PAF's are 42 Plain Enamel for those that don't know) in the slug position. It's pretty much THE taylor made 59/C hybrid neck recipe, if you were looking for similar deltas.

The A2 recommendation is simply an opinion. You guys can do what you want. But I think it'll be the right mix for the neck to balance with the bridge. There's no rule that says neck/bridge sets have to both be A5 or both A2.

The "Burning Gates" would excel in both 24 and 22 fret guitars. You guys would probably love it.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

This would be "educated speculation"

Perpetual Burn development did not begin until after I'd left the company. So I am not speaking as a former employee confirming the spec, nor have I taken one apart as a consumer for measurement. Based on what I know about wire and bobbin size, you can not fit that amount of 42 regardless of the insulation thickness. I believe it's 43, like an underwound Custom coil, or overwound Demon coil. You can see in photos that it's not Plain Enamel. It has the color of a Poly wire. Some photos make it appear more reddish which can mean thicker build coating, but you can order the red tint or clear in single build or heavy build.

Point is, assuming the Perpetual Burn is not a hybrid (which has never been discussed as far as I know) you'd be getting a ~6k 43AWG Poly coil up against the fretboard and a good PAF coil (PAF's are 42 Plain Enamel for those that don't know) in the slug position. It's pretty much THE taylor made 59/C hybrid neck recipe, if you were looking for similar deltas.

The A2 recommendation is simply an opinion. You guys can do what you want. But I think it'll be the right mix for the neck to balance with the bridge. There's no rule that says neck/bridge sets have to both be A5 or both A2.

The "Burning Gates" would excel in both 24 and 22 fret guitars. You guys would probably love it.

Burning Gates is now sealed. Same with Demon Lover.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

This would be "educated speculation"

Perpetual Burn development did not begin until after I'd left the company. So I am not speaking as a former employee confirming the spec, nor have I taken one apart as a consumer for measurement. Based on what I know about wire and bobbin size, you can not fit that amount of 42 regardless of the insulation thickness. I believe it's 43, like an underwound Custom coil, or overwound Demon coil. You can see in photos that it's not Plain Enamel. It has the color of a Poly wire. Some photos make it appear more reddish which can mean thicker build coating, but you can order the red tint or clear in single build or heavy build.

Point is, assuming the Perpetual Burn is not a hybrid (which has never been discussed as far as I know) you'd be getting a ~6k 43AWG Poly coil up against the fretboard and a good PAF coil (PAF's are 42 Plain Enamel for those that don't know) in the slug position. It's pretty much THE taylor made 59/C hybrid neck recipe, if you were looking for similar deltas.

The A2 recommendation is simply an opinion. You guys can do what you want. But I think it'll be the right mix for the neck to balance with the bridge. There's no rule that says neck/bridge sets have to both be A5 or both A2.

The "Burning Gates" would excel in both 24 and 22 fret guitars. You guys would probably love it.
Thank you for the insight, Frank. The idea of an underwound Custom coil is great! Or an overwound Demon coil, if we decide to go the hexhead screw route... which is looking better by the minute, if you ask me.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

Thank you for the insight, Frank. The idea of an underwound Custom coil is great! Or an overwound Demon coil, if we decide to go the hexhead screw route... which is looking better by the minute, if you ask me.
Isn't that basically what I said? :chairfall

LOL
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

How about making it a SH-6n/Screaming Demon hybrid? The coils would be mismatched but on the hot side. You could make it double screw, or better yet, screw/hex like the Demon. I have heard lots of good comments on the Demon in the neck position, and I myself love the SH-6n, though I did put an A4 in mine. I would say that stock, this pickup should come with a UOA5 though.
Nothing at all like what I suggested eh?
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

As said above, if this is going to be a match for the 59/C hybrid, wouldn't that dictate that it would have the same slug/screw setup, since that does affect tone and as such would have the same characteristics?

Sent from my Moto X 2014 using Tapatalk
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

As said above, if this is going to be a match for the 59/C hybrid, wouldn't that dictate that it would have the same slug/screw setup, since that does affect tone and as such would have the same characteristics?

Shhhh....quiet you and your logical deductions. They have no place in a forum designed pickup.

This is going to turn into a Screamin' Demon/Fuglybucker hybrid with half an A9 and half an A3, staggered slug/hex poles and only available in bright pink!

;)
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

IMO you need to get this sorted out:

We left off with the basis of create a neck p'up to tone- and output-wise be the missing companion of another "bro-made" p'up that made it to became a production p'up: our own Bach2Rock's love child, the '59/Custom Hybrid".

....

We get to decide if the "Hy-Bro" should be based on matched/mismatched coils from existing designs, like a neck '59/Jazz or whatever coils you can think of, based on past member's or own experiences, or creating a whole new p'up from scratch, giving the Custom Shop the burden of the new p'up's R&D.


Some people are advocating a "neck '59/Custom", and some people are apparently throwing that out the window in favor of completely different hybrid. If the pickup is to be a "neck '59/Custom", then there shouldn't be much to discuss, that would all best be left to the Custom Shop since they must have extensive experience in simply making neck compliments to to bridge pickups and vice versa. Changing the slug/screw config, deciding on the magnet type etc. would make their job harder, maybe even impossible.
 
Re: Forum p'up v. 2.0: aka "Hy-Bro" 2015

IMO you need to get this sorted out:




Some people are advocating a "neck '59/Custom", and some people are apparently throwing that out the window in favor of completely different hybrid. If the pickup is to be a "neck '59/Custom", then there shouldn't be much to discuss, that would all best be left to the Custom Shop since they must have extensive experience in simply making neck compliments to to bridge pickups and vice versa. Changing the slug/screw config, deciding on the magnet type etc. would make their job harder, maybe even impossible.

I agree... If this is suppose to be a 59/C neck there is not really anything to discuss. We shouldnt be chasing circles around double screws as it makes no sense for a 59/c neck
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top