But so far, I'd say:
Antiquitys have the livliest tone, some good quack but not as much quack as the Jerry Donahue, and the closest to a "Roy Buchanan" vibe.
Nocasters have the brightest, clearest tone.
The Jerry Donahue has the quackiest tone, like my '51 Tele, and is my fave by just a hair!
Fralin Blues Specials have the highest output and win the "balls with clarity award" (to cop the Guitar Player review wording) and probably the best overall neck pickup tone...like a smooth Strat.
I am really excited about the new Tele pickup sets MJ is custom winding for me...probably won't get them for another month tho!
They'll be an Antiquity version of the Jerry Donahue lead pickup, Antiquity version of the Tapped Tele lead pickup Seymour and Curly have (something like 6.6K and 10K) and a special Antiquity version of the "Strat tone in a nickel covered Tele neck pickup" offered by the Duncan Custom Shop.
I am especially looking forward to the tapped Tele lead as my original pickup in my '54 Tele only measures abrout 6.2K! To weak for a killer lead tone but gorgeous for rytyhm when combined with the neck pickup. With the Tapped Tele lead pickup I should be able to get both a great rythym tone and a little something extra for soloing.
At least that's what MJ is telling me. She's a cool lady!
Lew