Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Diego

New member
I want the analog delay sound. Badly. I love that lo-fi thing, it's such a rich texture.
The clean digital delay sound doesn't do much for me.
With that in mind, I have two possibilities:

1) Buy a Digitech Digidelay. I know, I just said analog, but it's got a tape delay emulation which I'm not sure how good it is because I didn't try it for long, plus a modulated delay.

The regular digital delay which I can actually control (unlike my Cube 60's which has almost no parameters) may come handy, and it also has a 4 second looper that I won't find myself using too often but who knows. Versatile, and it's also cheaper than my #2 choice. But it's digital. And I'm not sure they're that reliable to being with. But then my amp is digital and I'm happy with it's sound, so it would be no heresy for me. It's an ugly pedal, too.

Anyway, here's #2:

2) Buy a EHX Memory Toy. A much simpler, analog delay with shorter repeat time, but less knobs, a simpler circuit, and a really great sound. It's a fair bit more expensive, and I'd lose the versatility from the Digitech. But I'd have something very nice in my growing pedal board, plus I understand EHX pedals are as reliable as an iron bench. It's also tiny and looks cool. :D

I've tried both but not for long enough, so here's my questions:

Is the Digitech (or most Digitech pedals) reliable?
A friend of mine's had hell with a Looper pedal they have, Jam Man or something. That puts me down a bit but it could be down to bad luck.

Is the tape delay on the Digitech actually good or it's fake sounding?

Is the EHX really worth the extra cash in your opinion?

Feel free to add your ideas and thoughts, or suggestions. Maybe another pedal I'm forgetting about?

Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

If you want the sound of an analog delay nothing will really be the "thing" unless you get one. The question really is a digital (DSP or other form) "good enough" to your ear then? What is "good enough" for someone else is hard to fit to your preferences. So I would say, if there is a delay you like the sound of, and you do not need tap tempo but that one.
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Is the memory toy at the top of your price range? I can give you a better recommendation if I know what you're willing to spend
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Yeah, I don't wanna go any further than the Memory Toy on the price.
In fact the Memory Boy's not too far, but it does get a bit painful.
Thanks for the input guys!
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

I know its not on your list but the MXR Carbon Copy is a great delay. Grab a used one if $150 is too much.
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

I agree with Chas. The Carbon Copy really is pretty versatile. It sounds good in front of the amp, sounds good in the loop, is VERY easy to dial in, and has the modulation button if the basic delay doesn't quite cut it. That being said, I don't have a whole lot of experience with delays, but after getting the Carbon Copy, I don't use my DD-6 at all.
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

The CC really jumps out of my price range even used... Here in Chile prices can be a bit wacky depending on the manufacturer.

I'll keep it on my list though.

I've been checking some sound clips and I'm starting to believe the Digitech isn't even close to the Memory Toy. The Toy sounds so lush and deep... plus the modulation which is kinda useless stock (way too wavy and seasick) can be tweaked with a microscopic pot inside the pedal.

I think I'll bite. :D
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

MXR Carbon Copy it's all you will ever need
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Yeah, I don't wanna go any further than the Memory Toy on the price.
In fact the Memory Boy's not too far, but it does get a bit painful.
Thanks for the input guys!

I've got a Memory Boy and I can get tones pretty much exacting on my buddy's DMM... I'd say go for the Toy, I don't think you'll be disappointed!
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

I have an analog Morley Emerald Echo, its is Lo-Fi Delay Bliss ! Ive seen them pretty cheap
on eBay. Just though it might be worth Ya checking out.
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Feel free to add your ideas and thoughts, or suggestions. Maybe another pedal I'm forgetting about?

Thanks!
Yeah I think there might be one that combines all the features you've mentioned...
Hmm...
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

My favorite was always the EH Memory Man(which along with almost everything else was stolen a few years ago). Mine was one of the originals, and I don't know if the new ones compare favorably. If they do, that's what I would get.

I also really like the Carbon Copy.
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Get every delay ever!!!!

25708_372417418343_507708343_3762063_7089928_n.jpg
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Sounds like the Deja Vu is right up your alley (digital and analog). I don't think it is too much more than the DD20 either
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Yeah I think there might be one that combines all the features you've mentioned...
Hmm...

Ahh Frankie, if I could only afford that beautiful thing. It's waaaaay out of my league. But I'll eventually have a few SD pedals... they're a thing of beauty. Meanwhile these Boss pedals will have to do. Not having any dealers here in Chile makes them a harder choice for me too. Can't try them, though I can trust you all guys on their quality.
There's a EHX dealer here, as well as a Zvex dealer. And some folks bring Duncan products, but pickups only.
In fact, I've never seen a Seymour Duncan pedal in the flesh. Only pictures.

It also just happens to be that I pulled the trigger on a Memory Toy and it's sitting right next to me on it's box. :D

But thanks for the suggestion Frank!
 
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

It also just happens to be that I pulled the trigger on a Memory Toy and it's sitting right next to me on it's box. :D
mmm... lately I have listened the TC Electronic Nova Delay and it sounds sweet, sweeter than my G-major's delay. I need to check my delay's parameter again. :evil: I hate to do that because it pulls me away of what i really want... just play guitar.
Anyway, I hope you enjoy your Memory Toy Diego. Tell us what you think about that pedal. :friday:
 
Last edited:
Re: Help me choose the right delay pedal for me! Digital or Analog?

Seymour Duncan Deja Vu. Analog sound and a really useable tap and ratio function. Great stuff.
 
Back
Top