Is the Custom5/Jazz set the most versatile SD set?

Also the heat of the humbucker makes no difference when the 100 watt amp is cranked for epic metal toanz. The only thing how heavily the pup is wound ultimately affects is how thick and compressed it is.
 
Also the heat of the humbucker makes no difference when the 100 watt amp is cranked for epic metal toanz. The only thing how heavily the pup is wound ultimately affects is how thick and compressed it is.

that's what i'm talking about, a good balance of thickness and dynamics, which doesn't seem to exist in the SD catalog, it's either one or the other which is a damn shame, many companies are proving that it's not impossible to have a reasonably hot pickup and still have a lot of dynamics...
 
Yeah I agree. My 8.4k Fralin bridge is very beefy compared to Duncans wound to that level. Using a double thick mag in a vintage or vintage hot hum boosts it and makes it thicker and beefier while retaining the dynamics of the vintage wind.
 
The JB/Jazz gets praise as best all round set, but IMO the JB is not a very good allrounder, the cleans are bad and it's not a very dynamic pickup, it's too loud to do anything subtle with it.

Would you guys agree C5/Jazz takes the crown for most versatile SD set? if not, why and which set would you say is the most versatile for someone who needs to cover all genres?

No, I wouldn't agree.

I dislike the JB almost as much as I dislike the the C5. Both hurt my ears. The JB is like a wooden pick in my ears and the C5 like a sharpened metal pick in my ears.

I think if you're after stellar clean and overdrive from one pickup set you also need a great overdrive pedal.

I use a Dover Drive. I'm not after chugga chugga tones tho. I like those British Blues tones and sweet Eric Johnson and Brian May melodic violin tones.

And I've learned to create the sounds I want from my pickups by swapping magnets.

Using either a 59 set or an Antiquity set, I put a roughcast A3 magnet in the neck pickup for stellar clean tones and a roughcast A2 in the bridge pickup for bluesy overdriven tones.

For a stronger output a roughcast A2 in the neck and a roughcast A5 in the bridge.

But to really push the amp you need a great overdrive pedal too.

None of my amps are designed for overdrive.

These days I'm playing through AC30's.
 
The Hybrid is about as hot as you can get before you start feeling the compression, and losing a balanced clean tone.
 
The Custom 5 I tried out was nothing more than a loud mouth 59B , same EQ curve just a louder pickup .
Did'nt really think there was that much extra compression either , just a hotter 59B .
 
I have to take back what I said about no virtuosos using duncan humbuckers, Greg Howe is actually using the WLH in the bridge, if it's good enough for him i might give it a shot, i did some searching on the forums and found this interesting comment about the WLH compared to the 59

"i much prefer the WLH set to the 59s.
They are not more present/brighter tho.
They have a lightly attenuated high end compared to the 59 but it feels better.
They feel like there is some real weight in the note without the compressed feeling of overwound/hot pickups."

that "weight in the note" is exactly what i have been missing from the 59 and is probably one of the reasons Greg is using the pickup, he likes pickups that feel hot but don't sound hot.
 
I have to take back what I said about no virtuosos using duncan humbuckers, Greg Howe is actually using the WLH in the bridge, if it's good enough for him i might give it a shot, i did some searching on the forums and found this interesting comment about the WLH compared to the 59

"i much prefer the WLH set to the 59s.
They are not more present/brighter tho.
They have a lightly attenuated high end compared to the 59 but it feels better.
They feel like there is some real weight in the note without the compressed feeling of overwound/hot pickups."

that "weight in the note" is exactly what i have been missing from the 59 and is probably one of the reasons Greg is using the pickup, he likes pickups that feel hot but don't sound hot.

i swapped a 59 set for a WLH set and was much happier. however the wlh, to me, were def more present/brighter. maybe not with treble, but def with mids pushed. Which is what i liked about them. man they sound awesome.
 
i swapped a 59 set for a WLH set and was much happier. however the wlh, to me, were def more present/brighter. maybe not with treble, but def with mids pushed. Which is what i liked about them. man they sound awesome.

oh yes, more mids would be very welcome indeed!
 
What about if playing mostly Rock (70s/80s/90s Rock)?

I have a Epi LP with a WLH set (and love it); but I am thinking of getting a Epi SG with different pickups for a little different sound. Keeping in mind I use a EHX Big Muff Pi with Tone Wicker + Maxon Analog Delay as my only effects.

Would a Jazz (Neck) & Pearly Gates (Bridge) be a recommended combo for this gear/music style?
 
What about if playing mostly Rock (70s/80s/90s Rock)?

I have a Epi LP with a WLH set (and love it); but I am thinking of getting a Epi SG with different pickups for a little different sound. Keeping in mind I use a EHX Big Muff Pi with Tone Wicker + Maxon Analog Delay as my only effects.

Would a Jazz (Neck) & Pearly Gates (Bridge) be a recommended combo for this gear/music style?

Getting to 90s music, I might put a Custom in there.
 
I wonder how a jazz bridge sounds, if i love the jazz neck i'd probably love the jazz bridge as well?
 
I wonder how a jazz bridge sounds, if i love the jazz neck i'd probably love the jazz bridge as well?

I've never used it but someone on here earlier was saying it wasn't as good as the neck. Scroll back a page or so on this thread and you can see the poster's feedback on it.
 
it feels like this has been asked a lot lately...jazz bridge is imo the most underrated pickup duncan makes. sounds like a brighter, tighter 59 in the bridge, and makes a hell of a neck pickup.
 
Back
Top