Re: Just how bad do Epiphone Les pauls suck?
The P90 Goldtop Les Paul is better than every Gibson Les Paul that I've played under 2,500
For some reason, those Goldtops ooze mojo, even with stock Epi pickups! I think the reason is that the stock P90's are expressive, even at low volumes. They have a lively sizzle to them, that you can surf with your finger tips/palms/strums. Regular Epi humbuckers sound like they have a pillow over them, suffocating the tone.
The Les Paul Standard Plain Top is supposed to be a thin-ish solid maple top cap...rather than a regular flame top on typical EPI LP Standard (with a thin/fancy maple veneer over an alder cap).
Epi can be sneaky as far as wood goes. They may/might put a Plain Top style veneer over a maple or cap on a whim, for any reason, at any time! I have not come across maple necked Epi's in the set neck variety...but Epi mahogany IS NOT real mahogany in the first place! It appears to be
Luan (Phillipine mahogany).
My Luan/Alder/Maple veneer Epi LP Std. (with pickup change), and Luan Epi Iommi G-400 sound good to me regardless of the pedigree. Both are Korean/Samick builds.
I don't think maple necks are a guaranteed "death rattle" on an LP body. Gibson has used them in the past, and the likes are a fave of Zakk Wylde. I borrowed/played an old Epi LP from the 1980's, and think the faster "attack" of the maple neck is something that could actually be desired.
Play each guitar, as an individual. Make up your mind. Each guitar is an individual.