Re: Let me introduce you to my guitars and help me pick my next.
If you are gigging, I going to suggest that you get a backup guitar to your Number ONE guitar.
Which guitar do you play the most? For me, I can't live without one of my G&L Legacys. I also play Les Pauls and 335s, but I would hate like hell to have to play a four-hour gig using only a Paul or 335. I use a Legacy for 65-75% of the songs we play, so I ALWAYS (when possible) take a backup to my Legacy. It might be an S-500, Comanche or Legacy Special, or even another Legacy...but if for some reason that guitar goes down, I can get through the gig with my NUMBER ONE-A guitar.
Ca-ca happens. You could get a gig and find that your Number ONE is in the shop. It could get stolen. (God forbid!) I've done gigs where...yeah, I had a second guitar, but I was miserable the whole night because it didn't feel right or didn't have the right sound.
If you are really tied into one guitar as your Number ONE, be it the Strat or the Epi, you need a Number ONE-A guitar. This guitar is going to be a clone--as close to the Number ONE as you need it to be. I don't favor a rosewood board over maple on my Legacys--I like both so that doesn't matter to me--some guys it would; I'm not that picky. You have to decide for yourself what you can live with when your Number ONE goes down.
I've been playing for a long time. I've played many guitars over the years, and own many now. I have Pauls and 335s and a bunch of G&Ls; I have 12-strings and acoustics and a couple of oddballs. What I don't have is a really wide variety of guitars. I don't have a jazz box, I don't have a Gretsch, a Ric or a pointy shredder. I know what works for me and that's what I buy. If you've played long enough to know what you like, and you're gigging, the concept of a Number ONE-A guitar makes a lot of sense.
It is good to have a variety of guitars--it can get you the right tone on a recording, and it can be a source of inspiration. If you've still got some learning and growing to do as a player, by all means, play a lot of guitars until you find find the ones that best suit your style. But if you are already locked in to that one guitar, get a backup--a CLONE--and THEN you can start building a tone stable.
Best wishes,
Bill