Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

  • Worthy

    Votes: 91 85.8%
  • Hype

    Votes: 15 14.2%

  • Total voters
    106
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

When you think about it the whole tube amp thing goes back to the first self replicating nucleic acid
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Worse thread than "Pickguard on or off?" or "Topwrapping, yes or no?" or one of the lowest "How can I sound like "Lsash"....

MARSHALL MADE THE SOUND OF ROCK and amps that go to 11
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Worthy, only if you play loud... so no wanking-bedroom players.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Everyone has their own experience of Marshall. Like or loathe the name and brand, however, it's impossible to deny the company has stood the test of time.

They're still here for a reason.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

I've liked all the ones I've ever played (tube only). My friend's early '80's JCM800 combo is still one of the best I've ever heard.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

I'm just curious as to why Marshall has become so revered and popular I want to know whaat guitar players truly think of Marshall amps.

i have tried many many amps and my old marshall jcm 800 was, by far, my favorite. marshalls are amazing amps. it provided me the best sound. for example, when cranked or at low volumes i could hear every single note chime through clearly when playing a bar chord. it also roared when cranked with an agression i've never been able to duplicate on any other amp.

every other amp make has been disappointing. too muddy. too much mid. not enough clarity. not enough oomph. just not right.

i considered getting a bugera since they are less expensive marshall knock-offs with, reportedly, better components. but why mess with something that is already just right.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

IMO Marshall peaked with the 1959 Super Lead, and have been gradually going downhill since then.

That said, if the only amps they ever made were the JTM45 and the 1959, the brand would still be worthy of its legendary status. The tone from the early Marshalls (and their reissues) is heavenly.

This is how I feel generally, although I haven't had experience with every model of Marshall.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

I voted worthy too

I have a JCM 900 Dual Reverb I got for about $550 or so

its the real deal! not much money

has a 1/2 power switch too so not super loud to deliver the goods. you have to play LOUD to get marshall sound.

very middy amp, not much bass at all even with bass dimed, very noisy amp...IT IS A MARSHALL WITH MARSHALL CHARACTER :)
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Everyone I know who hates Marshall amps have only tried MG15s. Those amps did a lot of damage to their reputation around where I am.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

My JMP 2204 from 1980 is the best thing in the world. So yes, totally worthy.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Worthy.

If you only play in your bedroom, save your money.

But you will understand the love for Marshall amps the first time you ever get to crank one onstage under hot lights, playing to a packed house that wants to rock. And that third and forth set, when the amp REALLY starts getting hot--well son, that's about as good as rock and roll ever gets.

Bill

(Mesa user who used to own a JCM 800.)
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Back in the day thats all you had. fender or Marshall. So When you have guys like Betts , Allman, Hendrix, Gibbons, Van halen, Angus Young using them , they were bound to become lengendary.

Even amoung the legions of amps made today , they are still very valid , becuase thats what the other amps are trying to base their tones on.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Back in the day thats all you had. fender or Marshall. So When you have guys like Betts , Allman, Hendrix, Gibbons, Van halen, Angus Young using them , they were bound to become lengendary.

Even amoung the legions of amps made today , they are still very valid , becuase thats what the other amps are trying to base their tones on.

It's remarkable how many new (and newer) amp makers claim to offer players a choice between "American" and "British" tones. Those words are code, and it's well understood what's meant by them.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

JTM45 with a pair of blue's on top and 55hz greenbacks on the bottom. Cranked. Telecaster/Jazzmaster, maybe a fuzz with a little chorus/reverb/flang/delay. Lovely.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Nothin better then to stand in front of a cranked full stack Marshall and pull out some Pete Townshend arm twirls. It's not just music you hear,it's music you feel.

I do have other amps but I love my Marshall's.
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

While they do sound good cranked, I really like the low intensity input on mine ('79 JMP MK II Master Vol). It's got less gain and output than the high intensity channel and sounds good at lower volumes as a result.

They are bright sounding amps in a lot of cases.

If you want pushed pre-amp to not sound stifled, you need to get it to rehearsal level volumes at least.

PS My experience is playing through Greenbacks, your setup could give you different experience
 
Re: Marshall amps hype or truly worthy?

Depends on which Marshall you mean.

The old hand wired ones......totally worthy.

The PCB JMPs and 800s.....construction suffered, but still worthy (most, well, after I mod them!)

The 900s......not worthy.

The 2000s.....kinda.

The newer ones: Sound ok, but horrible, horrible construction. Full of SMCs and other junk that has no place in a tube amp. If it breaks, forgettaboutit, its a disposable lighter. Like a computer motherboard full of SMCs, you replace the board or chuck it.

But all in all, it is the sound of rock and roll and has been for near 50 years.
 
Back
Top