Modeling amp technology still lagging

Mr. B

New member
Its been a couple years since I posted a thread commenting that I thought Modeling Amp technology peaked with the VOX AD60VTX models (the blue grills) and I still feel like they are the top of the pile.

Think about it. Everyone (including vox) has jumped on the bandwagon; Peavey, Fender, Line 6, Marshall, Roland, but no one has really surpassed the old blue faced vox amps as far as my ears can tell.

Seems like everyone focuses on adding a few more useless effects, obscure amp models, and bells and whistles, instead of focusing on making the models sound more like a real tube amp. So please, I'm not talking about modeling amps not containing enough features, I'm talking about the tone and feel of the amps they are supposed to be "modeling". All of the amps I have tried since the blue face Vox models have seemed less authentic in tone and feel.

The new vox VT models are ok, but they don't sound as real (especially the clean amp models) as the much older blue face models. The rumored hig-end "Black Diamond" vox amp never surfaced. Most of the newer offerings have simply been smaller and cheaper versions of what we have had for years. Fender Cybertwin SE hasn't been updated in a decade as far as I know. Line 6 spider is not even in the running for realistic tones. Its great if you want overprocessed tones with lots of effects.

The only unknowns to me are the Peavey and the Marshall. I've heard the solid state version of the Peavey Vypyr and was not impressed. I am hesitant to order the tube version, since everyone's seem to be crashing and burning on a regular basis. The Marshall, I haven't heard in person yet, so maybe there is some hope there.

Ok, I've made my case for modeling technology being at a stand still for too long. What are your opinions on the matter? I'd like to hear any reviews or recommendations on amps I have not played.


P.S. Please don't bother posting your diatribe on tube amps and how they are superior to modeling amps. We all know that. I have tube amps by Fender, Marshall, Peavey, and Vox, but I still like the versatility and convenience of Modeling amps as well.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

I don't think that there's enough interest from the guitar community to really push development of new stuff into high gear. Early modeling was pretty crappy so there was a stigma attached to the stuff. Then look at the resale value of modeling stuff . . . which isn't too great around here. Development is expensive. Why come out with bigger and better when everyone seems to prefer designs from 50 years ago?

EDIT - I thought the modeling on the Line 6 Variax guitars was not too bad actually, now that I think of it.
 
Last edited:
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

The Axe-fx sounds pretty good so does the Vox ST. I do like the Blue grill Vox too though even more than say the Spider Valve.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

Anyone spend time with a Hughes & Kettner ZenTera? I always wondered what they sounded like since Alex Lifeson used a pair of those onstage, along with a pair of Triamps. Must not have been total crap. But cheap they were NOT.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

I've heard the solid state version of the Peavey Vypyr and was not impressed.

I really like Peavey's older "Transtube" solid state sound....to me it was the best solid I have ever heard. I can play on one without feeling like I am being lied to.

They then incorporated that into some of there effects processors to make some pretty cool preamps (Profex and Profex II), then those preamps were re-designed and stuck into amps (Transfex). They have really cool tones, but always lacked the proper high end features, like decent switching times and some of the effects were a little subpar. They might be considered a modelling amp before the term was popular.

...but, overall, I thought Peavey solid state really peaked with the Transfex series, and instead of addressing those few issues that would have made them real contenders they dove off into cheap tube amps that don't sound as good their previous models and the Vypr modelling stuff.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

The Axe FX, the GSP1101, theres a few out there now that are much better, the sounds have gone from sterile and passable to actually convincing.

I think there have even been some demo's on youtube where you're like, looking at a classic amp, listening to some guy play it for like 4 minutes, and then he turns the camera to the side and you see a modeler.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

Nothing beats the real thing. If you want a Marshall tube sound, get a Marshall tube. Simple as that. Modeling tech will always lack in those areas. It's getting closer, but not enough.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

When modeling meets tube, you can get a little closer. Check out the Randall RM series. It's all tube but uses the circuit boards in the pre-amps that are modeled after vox, marshall, peavey, fender, mesa, etc. Although I don't know if that actually counts as modelling.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

I've looked into the Axe-fx online, but all the clips and demo's I can find are effects drenched tones. The very few times you can find what sounds to be a dry amp tone in a clip, it actually sounds pretty crappy to me.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

Nothing beats the real thing. If you want a Marshall tube sound, get a Marshall tube. Simple as that. Modeling tech will always lack in those areas. It's getting closer, but not enough.

Please re-read the last paragraph in my original post. :smack:
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

When modeling meets tube, you can get a little closer. Check out the Randall RM series. It's all tube but uses the circuit boards in the pre-amps that are modeled after vox, marshall, peavey, fender, mesa, etc. Although I don't know if that actually counts as modelling.

That isn't modelling, those are all tube circuits - nothing is "simulated" anywhere. I used to own an RM100, they are really nice amps.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

Chris Broderick? He's a MONSTER player.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

I've looked into the Axe-fx online, but all the clips and demo's I can find are effects drenched tones. The very few times you can find what sounds to be a dry amp tone in a clip, it actually sounds pretty crappy to me.

I have had that same problem with what I have heard of the Axe-Fx, but I will say I will own one for the effects as I doubt that the Axe-Fx will provide adequate preamp tones sitting next to a Bogner Fish and Recto Recording Pre.

The effects, memory, and processing power have elevated the Axe-Fx to a status worthy of my "rack of doom"....LOL
 
Last edited:
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

The guitarist for Megadeath is touring using the Axe-fx for what it's worth.

Megadeath is not exactly what comes to mind when I think of vintage tube tones, but, I guess that is cool if someone trusts this unit enough to tour with it.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

The Digitech GSP 1101 sounds more authentic to me. I didn't know about that one. The dry amp clips on their site sound pretty good.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

Once again I'm going to big up the little line 6 flextone. Can't say how it compares to Vox stuff (old or new) but it's a pretty good sounding amp. No it doesn't sound exactly like a tube amp... then again some tube amps sound pretty rubbish, much worse than the flextone (I'll use the vintage modern as a great example of bad valve tone).
Ok, so it's not got that last little something, but still a great sounding amp with enough models for most people.
Why anyone would buy the spider valve thing when the flextone sounds better is beyond me.
From what I've heard the spider is one of the worst sounding modelling amps out there, the flextone is just in a different class.
 
Re: Modeling amp technology still lagging

Axe-Fx is there. And $2000+. But they are the undeniable top-o-the-heap.

I have never heard a blue-grille VOX, but I love my silver-grille AD series.
 
Back
Top