It's true. The guy at the Big Box said so. I asked "What is your cheapest analog delay (don't ask...). And he explained that right over here we have some digital delays and that that was what most guys are using...
Wow. You guys need to get over the analog thing.
Why get over analog???
Thats the sound I like in a delay pedal so thats the pedal I use...
I'm with ya Bro.
And that goes for any modulation..chorus, phasing, etc. I like analog far better compared to the digital stuff I have ever owned, heard or used. That said, I am not terribly experienced with some of the "analog emulator" digital pedals out there these days so some of them may be pretty good/good enough for me, IDK.
No I like to spit out rubbish in spades.....it is da wayz of der interwabzez...Have you even played one in person?
It is simple to understand, really. Look at the size of the Echoplex. By the time a sound bounces around in there a big sound has to come out. The El Cap has a much smaller enclosure. It stands to reason that sound waves bouncing around inside an enclosure that small can't accurately emulate the big box sound.
This isn't rocket science.
Maybe an El Cap needs to be rehoused in a big wooden box...that might help!
I regret that I've never had the opportunity to play a tape delay. That said, I would be unlikely to buy one just because of the size, cost and possible maintenance issues. I really didn't buy an El Cap believing it to be an accurate emulation of tape. I just wanted a delay with pristine (albeit digital) repeats and the El Cap happens to include a nice sounding reverb.
But, yes .... if the El Cap were in a large wooden box with the inside surfaces urethane coated to preserve high end detail and with two reels of magnetic tape liquid nailed to the bottom it would probably then more accurately emulate the sound of a tape delay. FWIW, I tried a a cardboard container with Scotch adhesive tape and it produced massive tone stick. There is no substitute for using high quality components for audio gear.
I certainly understand why people have their strong preferences for delay types. I just happen to like both analog and digital. My signal path is all analog except for the inclusion of the latter, and I am willing to live with any slight compromise it may induce.
Ya know, size, cost and up keep are the big issues people toss around when talking about tape delay units and why pedals, emulators or digital units are "better"...
I have never had to spend big bucks on work yet and even when the time comes if you spend a little cash now and then you're good for long periods of time...
As to the size, that is simply as issue of convenience and I am of the opinion that people that are too lazy to use lots of and or large gear because it is not convenient simply don't derserve the best tone available!
Also, FWIW, I paid less for my Echoplex units than many new digital units that are supposed to sound "like" tape...
In your opinion, how does the Fulltone unit compare to the Echoplex?
One thing I like about digital delays is you can get exact delay times to match the time signature of a song.