NPD: TC Electronics Plethora X5

Mincer

Administrator
Staff member
TC Electronic Plethora X5 is an interesting small pedal incorporating all of TC's digital Toneprint pedals in one multieffect. You can put effects in any order, and have as many as 5 of the same effect in a row, organized in pedalboards. I had a few of TC's single pedals before, so I thought this might be fun. Updates at the beginning of the year added a simple looper and a phaser (nd a few other things). I had been using a Line 6 HX Effects, and wanted a smaller board that doesn't depend on an external expression pedal. The Plethora uses MASH switches, which sense pressure as well as on/off state: you can turn an effect like delay on with a switch, and then press the switch and hold it, increasing the pressure. This can do a whole host of things, like increase feedback, delay time, etc all at once. It is really a great idea. It is awesome on Leslie sounds, as you can map the speed to increasing the pressure with your foot. All 5 switches have this, and you can map 3 parameters on each effect to the MASH switch.

Now the effects quality is really crisp and clear, like you would expect any TC Electronics pedal. Diving in, however, there are some serious shortcomings here. It doesn't have to do with the sound, but in the ergonomics of programing, saving, and setting up custom boards.

There is a PC and Bluetooth app for programming. But, you don't have to use it. If you don't use it, though, you have essentially 3 parameters of each effect that you can tweak. For instance, the Flashback delay can map delay time, feedback, and mix to the 3 parameter knobs. What if you want to alter the mod speed? Or EQ of the delay? Or any of the dozens of parameters per effect? You need the app. But you still need to access things on the pedal too. So I balance the ipad and pedal on my lap while I hold a guitar, and have to tweak both. Testing the MASH switch requires some serious weight on the pedal as it is pressure sensitive, so you have to move the pedal to the ground to test that function, picking it back up to get in and out of the different modes. How fun!

One of the selling points of this pedal is that it has dozens and dozens of artist presets/Toneprints. These are fantastic, until you realize you can alter only 3 parameters of each preset on the pedal itself- the rest of the dozens of parameters can't be edited in the app. So it you love a Steve Morse delay, but want to change the EQ of the delay a little bit, you simply can't.

Other thing about this pedal is that there are no drives at all. Most likely because they don't make digital versions of their analog drives. So if you get your drive from a pedal, you have to bring that pedal. It adds a pedal, 2 cables and another power supply.

The editing makes me want to throw it through a window. It is simply the most un-intuitive app I've ever used. It feels like it is a beta release. Not being able to edit artist Toneprints along with the need to still access the pedal itself when using the software would make this a nightmare at a gig if you need to change something.

TC Electronics also promised many updates on this pedal, but it hasn't been updated for 9 months or so. So while the whole concept is pretty good, it is just poorly executed. The TC Electronics forum is full of people complaining about lack of updates and terrible implementation of the the editing software.

I will give it a few more days to see if I decide to keep it. Right now, the HX Effects is a much better purchase with seriously thought-out editing.
 
Oh man. I had not heard about this pedal and when I started reading your review I thought it was super promising. I also have used some of their pedals and liked them. Then I kept reading lol
 
Yeah, I thought it ws super promising, too. Great idea, but it was like the project ran out of money and they got bored.
 
Can you save the artist TonePrint as a user patch and then edit that? I would suspect they are working in something to replace it.

Nope. The editor used to make the artist toneprints is different from the public version release. The artist or tc made toneprints that they provide for download have also sometimes had present functions mapped for the knobs as well.

This isn't a desktop unit though so most wouldn't place it up on a stand for use & it's better for those that have dealt with the toneprint pedals in the past such that the editor isn't difficult to deal with for them. I only have their flashback delay so I'm familiar with editing that one on the phone, the Hall of Fame reverb would take me awhile to get used to for making custom patches. But that's probably the appeal of the toneprint pedals to customize it for personal preference, you can get rid of the feedback function on the knob & assign it something else or have it do two or three things along it's travel range.
I never liked their smash function much though.
 
Maybe 25 years ago. These days Zoom manages to piss off a lot of gear snobs who spend thousands on pricey effects chasing the perfect tone (or simply just satiating a habit). Have your Kleenex handy as the dude from JHS says.
 
Can you save the artist TonePrint as a user patch and then edit that? I would suspect they are working in something to replace it.

This isn't possible. You only get the 3 parameters (out of literally dozens) that you can edit. If you take it as it is, you are golden. But no one does that. There is always something you want to change, even slightly.

This pedal is really a great idea, but it seems the idea ran out of steam. It was released originally with just a handful of pedals, and they added more during the last update. But the update is almost a year old, and it doesn't seem like anyone at TC is intent on finishing or developing this project.

I am also used to Line 6 and Fractal, whose developers are really active online. TC Electronics isn't on any forums, so you can't have direct contact with suggestions. It is a shame as this pedal sounds really good. It is just infuriating to use.
 
Back
Top