SH5's in SG's

Re: SH5's in SG's

Have stock magnets taken on some kind of sacred significance? The manufacturer has no idea what guitar/wood/amp you have, or what genres of music you're playing. They're shooting for one-size-fits all. That's not going to please everyone. We know how different a PU can sound in a Strat vs an LP. With about 10 kinds of alnicos available at Addiction, how can anyone dismiss the other 9 as not viable, without even trying any of them? It's seems kind of narrow-minded to assume that stock magents are the best, especially since most PU makers only use one or two kinds of alnico in their entire line. Doesn't DMz use A5's as their only alnico, and Gibson's current production only has A2's and A5's. There's so much more that HB's and P-90's have to offer. Why not be sure that you have the best magnet in your PU? Look at how many used PU's are for sale online; many of them could work for their intended application with the right magnet to move the EQ in the right direction.

You have completely misrepresented what I said. I have no problem with magnet swaps. I have a problem when I open a thread and that seems to be the end all be all answer to all pickup questions, because it isn't. Sometimes it's like putting a band-aid on cancer.

Sometimes the stock pickup is the right thing, but I see very few threads around here that actually suggest that. I don't think stock magnets have a sacred significance, but some around here sure think that magnet swaps do.

And don't accuse me of being narrow minded when it's pretty clear that I am not the guilty party here.
 
Re: SH5's in SG's

There are so many different pickups in the world that magnet swap is more a fine tuning to a pickup you already like but it's not exactly "there". If you don't like it, a magnet swap won't save you in my opinion.

Also when manufacturers make a pickup, they try to reproduce a certain timbre, with a specific note definition, string clarity, tightness, EQ etc and that is achieved by combining a particular wind with a magnet. That wind is made with a specific magnet in mind and together they compose a very finely tuned combination of timbre-EQ-clarity-sensitivity-compression-note tracking etc. Messing with the magnet can fix one but hugely mess up another of those balanced factors.

It's good to try new things though. Because a messed-up factor of the pickup could counteract with a messed-up factor of your guitar in a good way. But I tend to think that very few winds accept magnet swaps good.

Anyway, trying the Customs is a nice idea as it sounds like what you want from the beginning as the guys said.
 
Re: SH5's in SG's

It is brighter than the DC, though.

Don't be mislead by the D/C resistance numbers.

Thats fair enough, but I still don't think it is what I am looking for from clips.

- Although the problem I am having is not being able to find SG's with SD's in them being demo'd.
 
Re: SH5's in SG's

Custom Custom. Mids are where the angry lives. I'm not a fan of the C8. Too much low midrange and not enough cut, for me. I couldn't cut at practice so the A2 went back in. I still don't understand how such a hot pup with an A2 can be such a pissed off little bastard, but it is.
 
Re: SH5's in SG's

Thats fair enough, but I still don't think it is what I am looking for from clips.

- Although the problem I am having is not being able to find SG's with SD's in them being demo'd.

My SG has a 59n and a Custom 5 bridge. If you want, I can record some clips for you using Amplitube. Just let me know the settings you would like in Amplitube (if you know the software, of course) and send me a Private Message so we can talk.
 
Back
Top