As you might guess from my sig, I'm inclined to agree with Rid. I'm willing to concede that there are some flavors of "universally accepted 'good tone'" but there are some classics that some folks love and others despise. For example, Santana has a tone that drives folks wild in both directions--some dig his tone while others don't. Sooooo, I guess I'm saying that, while there are some tones that might be able to get consensus about their quality, I don't see that happening with one being "best". I suspect that Drew, Krankguitarist, and TO would have a hard time agreeing on what OD pedal was "best", simply because their tastes are very different.TwilightOdyssey said:Okay, I had to really think about that post. I disagree, but I will explain why.
I think that there is a universally accepted 'good tone'; we all know it when we hear it, it doesn't have to be expained, debated, or analysed. Of those acceptable good tones, there probably is a 'best' but I think that it will always be narrowed down to 'top 10 guitar tones'; with a big enough poll, I bet you that most guitarists will be astoundingly close on their choice, aside from the wacky people out there as well as the contrarians, like Rid.![]()