Re: What are your top 5 "Grail" tones?
Good question!
Here's a variety of tones I love:
Malcolm Young's rhythm tones define "CRUNCH". And Angus has one of the best lead tones in rock.
For Strat, Hendrix of course. But look at what Eric did with it on his first solo album...totally funky. And I love his modern tones, like on "Forever Man". Robert Cray on "Strong Persuader". Stevie's cranked tones as in "Crossfire" juxtaposed with "Riviera Paradise" or "Little Wing". Another guys who brings the tone on a Strat is Henry Garza of Los Lonely Boys, a very underrated player.
I love Santana, but sometimes his tone can be a little flubby on the bottom end. I like his playing on the duets with Rob Thomas and Michelle Branch.
I love my 335s, and I can get close to Larry Carlton's tone. Ah, if only I could play like that! And then B.B. King...different players and tones, but both definitive.
So many great LP players, but I'd have to single out Billy Gibbons. And I guess Don Fielder and Joe Walsh of the Eagles for their great clean and pushed tones. Kossoff.
Don Rich with Buck Owens had Tele tones to die for. R.I.P.
For jazz, I like Wes Montgomery, and George Benson's "Breezin' tones. Nick Colionne is good too. And for more fusion-type tone, I love Buzz Feiten. Yeah, THAT Buzz Feiten. Check out his work with keyboardist Neil Larsen.
And for great rock tone, Terry Kath of Chicago. "I'm A Man" and "25 or 6 to 4". Blistering.
Jim McGuinn and a Rickenbacker 360 12-string.
There are so many great acoustic players, hard to know where to start. Paul Simon, James Taylor, Stephen Stills for a few. A Martin guitar and a good engineer will get you there. I should also give kudos to Stills for his electric work. Check out his wah-wah work on C,S,N&Y's "Carry On/Questions" on the Deja Vu album.
As you can see, I have eclectic tastes.
Bill