I have 4 pups to choose from to go with a brobucker. PC, PG, 59, or Seth. Which would be the best match? In a les paul style guitar, for classic and hard rock through a jcm800 or blues deluxe.
The only suggestion on your short list that I would avoid is the Phat Cat. I have personal experience of the BB/PGN combination. Works well. For my tastes, the '59N would be improved by changing the bar magnet to AlNiCo 4. To my shame, I have still yet to try any Seths.
While I have not played a Brobucker, I did at one time have a 10k Alnico II Antiquity (User Group Day Pickup) in a Gibson Les Paul of mine. I'm not sure how close that is to a Brobucker or not seeing as how my pickup had a degaussed magnet. I had it paired with a Seth Lover and they were perfect for each other. I thought the Seth was a lot warmer, and it went very well in the neck slot with my 10K Antiquity.
I have 4 pups to choose from to go with a brobucker. PC, PG, 59, or Seth. Which would be the best match? In a les paul style guitar, for classic and hard rock through a jcm800 or blues deluxe.