Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why?

Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why?

  • 25.5 inch traditional Fender scale

    Votes: 15 46.9%
  • 25 inch PRS Carvin Kiesel scale

    Votes: 5 15.6%
  • 24.75 inch traditional Gibson scale

    Votes: 12 37.5%

  • Total voters
    32
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

Don't the double dots mean hold up here hoss?
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

While from the look of my collection, I’m pretty well split. I do tend to gravitate toward 24.75 scale guitars. I like the feel of the strings more so than on 25.5 scale. Plus, I feel like the shorter length imparts a tad bit of growl to the tone that I don’t seem to get from 25.5, it’s probably mostly in my head, though.

I only own two 25 scale guitars, my PRS hollow body (HB 1), and my Carvin acoustic / electric.

Both of my full on acoustics are even roughly 24.75 in my granddad’s 000-18 and my newish Collings CJ-35


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

I think 22 frets vs 24 is much more of a big deal to me. I can actually get used to 24.75" scales. I can't get used to 24 fret guitars, and won't even consider them.
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

I think I notice 21 vs. 22 frets somehow more than I notice 22 vs. 24 . I tend to use whatever frets are available yet don't really miss them when they're gone. I do get people disliking the neck pickup sound from 24 fret guitars.
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

I think 22 frets vs 24 is much more of a big deal to me. I can actually get used to 24.75" scales. I can't get used to 24 fret guitars, and won't even consider them.

I think I notice 21 vs. 22 frets somehow more than I notice 22 vs. 24 . I tend to use whatever frets are available yet don't really miss them when they're gone. I do get people disliking the neck pickup sound from 24 fret guitars.

Yeah, that's my issue.

I tend to agree with both of you. I definitely notice if I am on a 21 fret guitar, which is why I don’t own one. On the other hand I usually don’t notice the difference between 22 and 24 frets from a playing standpoint. I don’t miss the extra two frets one iota when I’m playing a 22 fret guitar, but at the same time if I’m playing a 24-fretted and doing some freestyle soloing I will go ahead and take advantage of the extra couple of frets (although I don’t spend a LOT of time up there).

I definitely like the richer, fuller tone of the neck pickup on my 22 fret guitars better than their 24 fret counterparts though. I guess that’s the trade-off.
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

Thinking about this a step further- If we're talking bass, I do notice. I really don't like 30" scale basses, 34" scale feels/sounds a lot better (have owned/played Ibanez, Fender & Gibson short scale basses.)
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

Thinking about this a step further- If we're talking bass, I do notice. I really don't like 30" scale basses, 34" scale feels/sounds a lot better (have owned/played Ibanez, Fender & Gibson short scale basses.)

longcat has a Squier Bronco short scale that's set up for a Jamerson-style tone with a Cool Rails bridge pickup & La Bella flats and it works really well. Other than that I don't care for the sound or feel of a short scale bass.
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

I do both Fender scale (G&L) and Gibson scale instruments, along with Martin acoustics at 25.34".

While I easily move back and forth better these, the 25" PRS scale just feels really weird to me.

Bill

Bill, you think the 12 fret models sound better?
 
Re: Which one of the 3 most popular 6 string scale lengths do you guys prefer and why

I have been interested in the guitars that use thinner wire after the 12th fret
 
Back
Top