Would you consider a Walnut neck?

Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

Why not......

Its always good to try out different things and see what they're like. One of my nicest/best toned strats has a 'hog body - which is sacrilege according to a good proportion of strat purists.

Fit that with a nice set of buckers that allow the wood to shine through and see where you go.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

I've always wanted an oil-finish walnut neck-thru with ash wings superstrat.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

Sure! But watch out for the weight of the neck (it can make it neck heavy). Walnut is also generally bright, so think about that when selecting pickups.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

I too was considering the weight of the neck. There are 500 different ways to compensate for whatever tone the walnut will impart, but not so many to relieve weight.

It's also important to consider that no Telegib would be worth it's weight without knob pointers.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

Neck? I'd consider a whole damn Walnut guitar!!!!

19-1375372436-5c9b5321b35e833bb21547f1d57d03c7.jpg
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

Those walnut LPs and SGs were heavy! They did a 'lightweight' version in the late 70s (the LP was as thin as an SG) but they were still heavy. And bright.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

No real benefit. The tone of quarter sawn maple with twice the weight
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

According to THE WOOD DATABASE, Black Walnut should be lighter than African Mahogany and those are the species Warmoth uses. And although it would be bright it should be less bright than Hard Maple. In that middle ground between Les Paul and Strat I want the sound to lean slightly to the LP side of center. I like that its pores seem to be similar to Mahogany ... which make me think they may couple sonically.

Warmoth suggests Ebony fretboards with Walnut backs, but I'm thinking that might bring out too much high end. I don't want "bright". I have a Tele for that.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

Sure! But watch out for the weight of the neck (it can make it neck heavy). Walnut is also generally bright, so think about that when selecting pickups.

So ... this is not the pickup room, but what would you suggest?
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

I can’t comment on whatever “the wood database” is publishing. I can only speak from my experiance with a couple of walnut bodies. Could those bodies have been particularly heavy? Sure, but with no upside and potential for down, why take a chance?
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

I think nk he body pictured in the OP would look great with a roasted maple neck.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

I'd go for walnut neck. I'm also the type of guy who'd go for an ostrich neck,imagine the bends you could get.
 
Re: Would you consider a Walnut neck?

I think the body pictured in the OP would look great with a roasted maple neck.

Ordered Roasted Maple 2-Piece neck with Roasted Maple fretboard (unfinished), 3 + 3 tilt-back headstock (Sperzel preps), 6150 frets, 10 - 16 compound radius, 59 Roundback profile
 
Back
Top