Re: Carol Ann Hs-2
Re: Carol Ann Hs-2
Just my 2 cents because I also coincidentally have a Goldfinger (45 watt) and used to have the Carol Ann OD3r.
First, the Goldfinger is about as good an amp as anything out there. Very versatile. Sparkling clean Ch1, driven Plexi on CH2. Overall, hard amp to beat.
I used to have the Carol Ann OD3r, but sold it by accident (long story, but I didn't really want to get rid of it). The OD3r clean is DELICIOUS, and any pedal sounds good into it. The Drive channels are very "dumblesque", lots of bottom end. Even at 35 watts or so, the OD3r is LOUD.
My only reason for even looking elsewhere than my Bogner Goldfinger is the size. It's a monste - head is 42 lbs and cab is 47. So, when Carol Ann offered a small combo, I was curious.
I just ordered one new. It says 18 watts 6V6, and takes 6L6 at 30 watts. So, it seems on paper the ideal amp.
Here's my thoughts on the HS-2 after playing it for a few days:
1. Not much headroom on the clean channel. I even switched out 6L6s and still a little crunchy. Even at level 3-4, it's breaking up. Don't get me wrong, the breakup is very nice sounding, but it leaves me no room for my pedals to do the job. The OD3r took ANY pedal and made it into gold, whilst this amp only sounded good with SOME of my pedals.
2. Not nearly the same sparkling clean sound as the OD3r (and the OD2, which my brother has, and sounds the same on Ch1).
3. Channel 2 on the HS-2 is pretty close to the OD3r, but sounds a little flat, not quite enough bite for my taste. Same bottom end growl, though.
4. Surprisingly not "boxey" sounding, like most combos are. Not quite as full as a separate cab, but pretty darn close.
So, this amp is going back, and I am going to try the new Satin, which has more headroom, unless I can find another used OD3r, which I have been unsuccessful in doing since I sold mine.