Re: The Distortion Poll
Always pedals. I set my amps to the onset of overdrive, so I have a full bodied clean tone by backing the guitar volume to 8, and then I use both overdrive and distortion pedals to get the really driven tones. I will often use one of each at the same time for saturated solos, the trick being to a) use great pedals and b) use great pedals that work well together.
To my ears the worst tone is preamp fizz, and unless you have a low wattage amp, getting power tube distortion means that you will be too loud except for concert stages. Even with low wattage amps it can still be too loud for club or bar gigs. I've heard hundreds of amps over the years, and of them only a handful delivered a great tone straight from the amp, and they were the sort of amps that are considered legendary, 60's AC30's, some 60's and early 70's Marshalls, a few HiWatts and a few handmade boutique amps, but not many. All of them were too loud for standard gigging conditions where you are trying to match a balance to the acoustic drum kit and still be in the FOH mix. So bring on the best pedals on the planet, and give me a good tone and versatility at a volume that keeps me in work!
Cheers........................wahwah