The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

wahwah

GumbyLoveologist


Some of you may be familiar with my 1968 Strat, known to many as the Old Dear. I wanted to share with you the story of her recent visit to an excellent local guitar repairer who has managed to breathe new life into what was already an excellent, long serving guitar. It began with me noticing an annoying electrical ‘clicking’ sound under the pickguard, and since she is the only guitar I take out on my weekly interstate gigs, I knew I needed to get it seen to immediately. I had heard of a guitar tech I had never used, and he came highly recommended. I called him and he was very familiar with my work and the guitar, admitting that he had been coming to see bands I was in dating back as far as 1989, so we were off to a good start. He told me that he was busy, but that he had a policy of prioritising professional player’s emergencies, so I could take the guitar to him immediately.

As soon as he heard the guitar, he asked how many different techs had worked on it over the years. Well, it’s probably been about a dozen different guys who have poked around in there. He obviously had very good ears, and he could tell that there was all kinds of ‘fixes’ and attempts to curb noise and provide treble bleed, etc. At this point, he gave me a couple of options. The first was to trace and locate the source of the clicking and eliminate it. The second was more radical. He asked if I would trust him to get rid of all of the stuff that was stifling the guitar’s natural tone. In short, he wanted to rip out her electrical guts and start again, simply and cleanly. I had a good vibe about this guy. I chose the latter.

The first thing to go was the shielding under the scratch plate. There he found two layers of the stuff, and set about removing every bit of it. As he was doing that, we discussed noisy venues with crap power, those soundchecks that have you freaking out about the noise levels in your rig, and the inherent noise of single coils. Soon all of the shielding was gone. I was experiencing a leap of faith.

He saw what the pickups were, mid 80s Duncans, SSL1, SSL1 RW/RP and SSL5. He agreed that we should stick with them. Everything else went, including a custom made, patent applied for noise reduction system and a treble bleed circuit. None of the circuitry was original to the guitar, so I had no qualms about watching it go. This was an overhaul, an overdue update, a fresh start. All new CTS pots and a Switchcraft pickup selector, selected, balanced and lubricated. He was meticulous with his soldering and wiring, explaining his choices as he went. The only modification to the original circuit was to include the bridge pickup under the second tone pot’s control. Other than that, he had a stunning collection of paper in oil caps for the tone circuit, ancient looking things from old Australian made radio sets. Eventually we would hand pick one, with the rest of the guitar put back together and two wires dangling from under the scratchplate with alligator clips so we could hear the differences in the circuit. As part of this process, we also tried the cap that was previously in there. It was like throwing a blanket over the amp. We stuck with our chosen PIO cap, the guitar was opened back up and it was wired into the circuit.

The results have been stunning. The tone of the guitar is wide open and potent. Punchy. I have done half a dozen gigs in the past couple of weeks and noise has not been a problem, at all. The guitar sounds better than it has for years, and it was already very good. Now it’s stunning. Here’s to all the good guitar techs, who put tone ahead of everything and challenge some accepted but debatable notions about functionality.



Cheers……………………….. wahwah
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

Enjoyed reading this and props to the guitar tech for a job well done! Love the guitar btw!
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

Strewth. Leo Fender knew what he was doing all along. :approve:
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

Awesome to hear that all is well Geoff. So did the tech give any indication of what may have caused that clicking? My guitar seems to suffer the same type of symptoms and to me it's like a static build up?
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

Glad to see she's still in service and serving you well. That guitar is a legend.
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

Awesome to hear that all is well Geoff. So did the tech give any indication of what may have caused that clicking? My guitar seems to suffer the same type of symptoms and to me it's like a static build up?

Hey Don, good to hear from you my friend. I've heard that before about the clicking being static buildup, could well be the case. Cold solder joint could also be the culprit. In this case, we kinda bypassed the diagnosis and went straight for the big solution to much more pressing issues.
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

I don't blame you mate as its your bread winner, sound and reliability are the key. Sounds like the tech knows his onions too, the idea of demoing the caps is very cool. Great stuff.
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

I don't blame you mate as its your bread winner, sound and reliability are the key. Sounds like the tech knows his onions too, the idea of demoing the caps is very cool. Great stuff.

Yeah, I gotta say, this guy was impressive. I've had a lot of techs over the years, some great, some better at talking than making guitars sound good. This guy is some kind of guitar whisperer, and his methods make a lot of simple sense, mixed in with some weird mojo stuff that shouldn't really make a difference, but does. It's a winning combination. I feel like I learned a lot just watching him work and hearing his ideas. On the other hand, he actually listened, which I've found many of them fail to do. Testing the caps by dropping them in and out of the circuit while I played was a good example of this. Find the value that works, and then the individual component, then when I heard something I liked, he would say, "Ok, that's the one," as opposed to, "Well these are the ones I like to use."

18 months ago I took this guitar to another tech in a 'snapped off vibrato arm' emergency, and within 5 minutes he had criticised every other tech in town, claiming that they were all fools and that he was the only one who did things 'properly.' His work was atrocious and all had to be undone. He may have known the technicalities and the measurements and details, but he knew jack about tone. In retrospect I can see that his attitude was an insight into his insecurity, because deep down, he must have known he was faking it. This new guy is the polar opposite, nothing bad to say about another tech, less talk and more work, and not a step taken without client approval. When the guitar was finished and I was playing it to check all was well, he said, "Looks like an old Strat, sounds like an old Strat." That was all he cared about.
 
Last edited:
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

i love that... looks like and old strat, sounds like an old strat.

do you mind telling what value cap you went with?
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

i love that... looks like and old strat, sounds like an old strat.

do you mind telling what value cap you went with?

Yeah, he said it all in that quote. A purist approach without pretence or anal retentiveness for its own sake.

It's a .022uf. It gave us the 'cleanest window' into the tone of the guitar, in keeping with my philosophy for the rest of my rig, broad, open and somewhat confronting, but incredibly rewarding when the input from the hands is strong and true.
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

Hey Don, good to hear from you my friend. I've heard that before about the clicking being static buildup, could well be the case. Cold solder joint could also be the culprit. In this case, we kinda bypassed the diagnosis and went straight for the big solution to much more pressing issues.

Good story with a happy ending. At last.

My 1966 Strat had the same problem. When my fingers brushed the pickguard, it would crackle in the signal. I read one option is to keep an anti-static laundry dryer sheet in the case and brush it over the pickguard before playing. But that only worked temporarily, in my experience.

In the end I shielded both the cavity and the guard and ensured they both touch and are grounded; and the problem has gone away permanently - that was 4-5 years ago and many gigs/recording sessions in between. I realize you guys took all that stuff out (since it's not how they were originally) but ... I think it's worth discussing the different solutions that work. Mine also has been rewired back to near-original specs; CTS pots, CRL 3-way switch, cloth pushback wire, two of the pickups are original, the other is a Duncan Antiquity that matches really well. It looks old like an old Strat and sounds like an old Strat. I have 2 other Strats but they hardly compare.
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

It's good that Old Dear was able to get a tummy tuck successfully.

:bigok:
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

At a certain point, Clapton retired his old Stats.I guess once they reach a certain level of usage , after enough things have been replaced or refurbished, that they no longer sound or play exactly like the original. That would be my belief. Hence the value placed on a original fine condition vintage Strat.Have you considered a reissue?The value of a beat to hell refurbished old Strat like yours is probably similar to a new reissue.
 
Last edited:
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

At a certain point, Clapton retired his old Stats.I guess once they reach a certain level of usage , after enough things have been replaced or refurbished, that they no longer sound or play exactly like the original. That would be my belief. Hence the value placed on a original fine condition vintage Strat.Have you considered a reissue?The value of a beat to hell refurbished old Strat like yours is probably similar to a new reissue.

It's easy to mistake cosmetic wear for disintegration, but it certainly doesn't necessarily equate. The playing condition of this guitar is kept to a constant professional standard, because it is a hard working and very well travelled guitar. Tonally, it only improves. The flaw with the thinking that an 'original fine condition vintage Strat' will be something remarkable is that there is a high likelihood that a 50 or 60 year old instrument that is in mint condition probably hasn't been played very much. There could be a couple of reasons for this. 1. It has been owned by an amateur or hobbyist. 2. It was a dog to begin with, and will always be a dog, and was therefore passed over by any serious musician. Sometimes both. Such a guitar is perfect for the collector or hobbyist, but won't survive in the world of professional musicianship. The paradox is that such a guitar will be far more expensive than one that has been constantly played and travelled all over the world. It is meaningless to the owner of the well worn guitar, because there is no consideration of resale value.

I was recently offered an endorsement deal by Fender Australia. Initially I was excited at the prospect, until I went to their Sydney warehouse and tried a dozen Strats from Mexican builds to US Custom Shop vintage reissues and signature series. There wasn't a guitar amongst them that could stand in for this one. They all felt cheap and sounded small by comparison. There is no comparison. Sure, in the absence of a truly beautiful sounding guitar, they could fulfil a role and be completely functional. But at the professional level, functional is not enough if you know there is something better to be had. Does Jeff Beck play the instruments they made in his name, based on his favourite? No, he plays his favourite, and the replicas are there in case of string breakage or possible failure. I would get closer by spec'ing out a Musikraft body and neck and hand picking the hardware and having a good tech align it into a good playable instrument that I could use for the outdoor summer festivals and any other harsh conditions that this guitar has previously endured. But it would always be a 'spare' guitar, I know this from experience. Nothing against Fender, they have done well to re-establish themselves in the marketplace, but there's nothing a new, green regrowth forest instrument can do to match itself against an instrument like this, regardless of how it might look cosmetically. Can you play it, will it sound like a guitar? Yes. Will it be the same or as good? No, it won't.

There comes a point where the perceived value or price point in dollar terms is irrelevant, and that is the point where you no longer consider the instrument or equipment as something tradable or as an investment. I have never considered the dollar value of this instrument, because it has always simply been my guitar. I'm a professional guitar player. Why would I want to sell my guitar? Or get a different one that isn't anywhere near as good? I'll just keep playing it, and keep it in excellent playing condition. That's the only approach that makes any sense to me.



Cheers................................... wahwah
 
Re: The Old Dear's Circuit Surgery

+1

If you find a guitar that has "it", buy it.
 
Back
Top