Re: Vivian Campbell's Dio tone from 1984 - which pickups
Hi.
Let's dispense with the friendliness and candor here because evidently it's creating a number of false impressions. And the only reason I post here now is purely for the sake of completeness and for those who are maybe keen on the outcome of the thread topic. The condescending posts are not necessary. I've been around a LONG time and have had a LOT of gear ("proper" gear) over the years. Just because I cannot play blistering fast Vivian Campbell solos doesn't mean I don't know the different between good, bad, and downright cr*p tone. And I don't understand why it's an issue in that I'm trying to duplicate the said tone. It's the tone that I want simply because I want it at this time and for a specific purpose. Also: my fault that I happened to joke about being OCD on this and let it slide thereafter. Let's not confuse OCD with not being satisfied with mediocrity. And at this juncture: playing style or skill has NOTHING to do with the issue at hand. There's nothing special about the first few barre chords to "Rainbow In The Dark" (as but one example) I assure you. And this is not a quest to find some "magic bullet" that's going to set me on the path to stardom (I should never have joked about this). It's a specific quest to get a specific tone out of the gear I currently have (and if that's not possible then so be it i.e. I'll ditch the lot and start over but I wasn't prepared to do that until I'd at least tried and hence this thread). And lastly: I started this thread thinking that MAYBE the pickups would help me to get this particular tone that I'm looking for at this particular time from FROM THE INSTRUMENT knowing full well it's a process of elimination. Well (as below) I've now eliminated pickups from the equation.
Oh and please before I go any further: could somebody please give me the correct term to use for a tone with lots of bass and lots of treble but no mids. Apparently my definition of "scooped" is incorrect.
I installed the DM SD yesterday afternoon. No great shake when compared to the stock Jackson pickup taken out. As I've noted previously: the stock Jackson pickup in this guitar was an incredibly hot pickup to begin with for some reason (to the point where I actually thought it may even have had some or the other issue or be of poor quality) and nothing like the stock pickup in my other Jackson. The DM SD is SLIGHTLY more articulate (and I do mean SLIGHTLY to the point where it could possibly even be the placebo effect to be honest) but that's about it. Certainly no difference in mid. tones. If anything it's more "shrill" in this guitar. As per a suggestion on another thread: am going to rewire in parallel to see what happens but I'm not holding my breath as this apparently accentuates highs notwithstanding that it may make the sound clearer. Based on this I'd be really surprised if even an SD Invader is going to make any difference (but it'll be worth testing when it arrives for the sake if it anyway).
And based on all of the above I'd have to surmise that it's guitar type (wood) and/or (unfortunately) shortcomings in the guitar amps. And like I said above: if this is the case well then so be it i.e. I'll ditch the whole lot and start over. If that necessitates buying two JCM800 heads (this time of the Master Volume variety that is i.e. nowadays I'll get jailed if I repeat my previous valve antics from yesteryear) and cabs. well then fine. I just really assumed that different pickups would make a big difference based on the Tone Profiles but evidently I was wrong. No problem at all saying "I stand corrected and I was wrong and thanks for the input". But at least I now KNOW just how much, or how little, different pickups make. Would this Jackson kick a JCM800 into overdrive with absolutely no effort??? 1 000% sure that it would. Is it "too much" for these CODE amps.??? Yes. Am I going to get this tone with my current setup??? Probably not. Have I been trying to get "Rolls Royce" sound out of "Toyota Prius" gear??? So it would seem. But I could not have said that with any conviction eight pages (of thread) ago. I guess the bottom line is (to anybody following this thread because they're interested in the actual topic): changing pickups, unless you have genuinely horrid pickups, is not going to drastically alter your tone. There's a whole lot of things that come into play and based on my personal experience here: pickups are a very small part (unless, as I said, you have absolutely atrocious pickups of course). That's my take on the topic as of today. Agree. Disagree. Whatever. Your experience is, and will be, different from mine.
By the way @devastone (thanks for the post by the way): the Marshall CODE amps. have guitar cab. speakers in them and not FRFR speakers (this confirmed by Marshall themselves in a direct response to myself at the beginning of this week). Apparently they were voiced specifically for the CODE range but they are definitely guitar cab. speakers. They say they were specifically voiced for the CODE range an not based on a particular model of Celestion (or anything else for that matter).
I suppose one last test I can do to prove or disprove some theories is to input all the settings from the chap with the white Charvel (posted somewhere earlier on the thread) into JamVOX (the guy was kind enough to email me his exact settings used for that video) and try that with this guitar and the DM SD (which is what is in that guitar) (and by the way and case in point: he most certainly doesn't have the chops, style, or technique but his GUITAR TONE is DAMN close to the studio versions i.e. he's playing chords for goodness sake) (but closest I've found to date and that with a $99 piece of software). Unfortunately this defeats the (my) object of getting this tone live though. But as I said: may prove a point. (To save those actually interested some precious time I've included the link below i.e. it's DAMN close).
Oh and some may find this info. useful in the future: the stock Jackson pickups are made by an outfit called "Belcat". Apparently a Chinese company making budget pickups. I don't know if I just got lucky with my two Jacksons but I can tell you this: there ain't a $80 - $90 difference between the Belcat pickups and these name brand jobs that's for sure. Same way there ain't a $4 500 difference between my Jacksons and my hand made jobby either. You live and learn (and pay) I guess.
Regards,
Dale.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-bjw7ZiNO0