I've owned all three, and I love them all. I prefer dyed ebony (ala ESP) to undyed, and crappy, faded, neglected rosewood is horrible, but nice dark rosewood is beautiful. Tone-wise, I found rosewood slightly less bright than maple and ebony, which can be good or bad. Maple-neck strats with single-coils are too bright for me, even though it's a nice shimmery brightness.