the sonic youth ones look THE BEST and they eliminate all the (in my opinion) useless "Rhythm Circuit" options
we just got a Blacktop at my shop and I'm loving the crap out of it every chance i get...awesome bang per dollar and i'm kind of wanting to get one to replace the Jaguar I just sold
but just knowing what you've already got in your stable, i think you should at least get the one with single coils. You have high-output humbuckers in every other plank of wood you own...I would hate to be in that situation.
anyway for me it depends on what you want...Sonic Youth wins for style...I wouldn't waste my money on a Mascis or a Costello unless I really wanted those specific paint jobs...otherwise i'd just try a few in the classic colors and buy the one that feels the best...
or if you just want a road warrior that you can thrash the crap out of, those Blacktops are great...lots of dudes would hate it but I loved how switching from the neck pickup to the humbucker was like night and day...perfect for my grunge-influenced habit of switching to a single coil (or splitting a humbucker) during my clean passages and using the full-bore humbucker for heavy parts...
eh y'know how it is...it's hard to tell a dude which guitar is the best guitar cuz most of 'em are at least "good"...you really shoulda just bought my Jag when you had the chance tho hahahaha