Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

I get where you're coming from Mantis. The actual statement seems to be the original poster taking that one sentence out of context which TM explains better in the video. Pretty sneaky way to start a thread war :P

I respect your experience like anyone who's been doing this longer than me so no hard feelings.
It's all good, we all can't always agree.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

I'm can listen to Mark Knopfler over the years as his gear changed. He always sounds like Mark Knopfler.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

I'm can listen to Mark Knopfler over the years as his gear changed. He always sounds like Mark Knopfler.

I can tell when he's playing a Les Paul without the poker chip. It makes him sound like a low-paid imitator.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

Total BS; your tone comes from you and the gear you choose. Cream would not be the band they were ifClapton used a Strat with garbled Fender combos and pedals like he did at their reunion concert.

I spent hours comparing Seymour Duncan pedals to the Vox Tonelab pedal board I have. If the Vox pedal board sounded the same or just as good as the SD pedals, I would not spend one dime on SD's products. But their pedals sounded far superior to the Tonelab, not just one, but all of them.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

Total BS; your tone comes from you and the gear you choose. Cream would not be the band they were ifClapton used a Strat with garbled Fender combos and pedals like he did at their reunion concert.

I spent hours comparing Seymour Duncan pedals to the Vox Tonelab pedal board I have. If the Vox pedal board sounded the same or just as good as the SD pedals, I would not spend one dime on SD's products. But their pedals sounded far superior to the Tonelab, not just one, but all of them.

I agree that there's a huge difference in sounds. However, if I only had access to one or the other, I wouldn't feel limited.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

Maaaaaan.... I don't care.

Gear matters some... but the player is the magic. How many web forums and You Tube videos have guys with a house full of boo-teek gear who manage to make it sound like a 12 year old plugged into an SS Crate amp?

Anyways... I dig Morello's thick tone and simple, but melodic hooks/riffs. But I coud care less what comes out of his mouth.

Carry on with your thread what will change absolutely NO one's mind regarding tone.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

If you have gear that gives you the sound you like and you get a "special feeling" it can inspire you to play in a way you may not have done otherwise
The right sound gets ideas flowing


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

He is, of course, 100% correct in one respect. I think that the real paradox is that this all comes from Tom Morello, of all people. Morello, after all, made so much of his name as an early exponent of the whammy pedal. Certainly there cannot be many guitarists as closely associated with an effect, or, for that matter, effects as closely associated with a particular guitarist? I don't mean to be rude here, but whilst I am sure that Morello would have written differently without that pedal, would listeners and guitarists have taken as much notice? Of RATM perhaps, but of him? Would Reverb have asked for his opinion if there were no novelties on his pedalboard?

I somehow doubt it. This also throws doubt on the subtext of what he is saying: if Tom Morello turned heads for his use of the Whammy pedal, and gear doesn't matter, then it necessarily follows that Tom Morello would have turned heads anyway. I'm sure there is much commendable to him and his playing, but to me it seems a bit too simple, and that he implicitly is trying to exonerate himself from being a guy who had the right toy at the right time.
 
Last edited:
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

*cough* thetoneking *cough*

That dude manages to make all expensive gear of any brand sound bland with his 18-year old playing.

What the hell...the fact that he can't play is probably what makes any gear sound like how it is supposed to sound: without any interference from the skill of the player that can mislead the listener. That's probably why gear makers keep throwing stuff at him for reviews.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

whilst I am sure that Morello would have written differently without that pedal, would listeners and guitarists have taken as much notice? Of RATM perhaps, but of him?
.

No. Tom Morello woulda a been Mick Mars of punk rock. I think he sucks very very bad. Sorry.

I just can't cope with the fact that guitar magazines actually condone stupidity like this. Well...Guitar World actually included Beavis & Butthead as one of 100 most influential people in guitar (April 1994 issue).

The beauty of electric guitar. If you can't play, you can hide behind what your gear is capable of doing.
 
Re: Your gear (all of it) does NOT matter !

No. Tom Morello woulda a been Mick Mars of punk rock. I think he sucks very very bad. Sorry.

I just can't cope with the fact that guitar magazines actually condone stupidity like this. Well...Guitar World actually included Beavis & Butthead as one of 100 most influential people in guitar (April 1994 issue).

The beauty of electric guitar. If you can't play, you can hide behind what your gear is capable of doing.
Unfortunately this is true. I've spent a long life with electric guitars and the only way to keep honest is to minimise the effects. I practice without an amp a lot too, just to make sure. Any rumours of me wearing a hair shirt and whipping myself with nettles are, however, exaggerated.

HTC One Mini 2 - Tapatalk
 
Back
Top