Re: Best "classic" Les Paul color?
If Heritage Cherry always looked like your pic, I'd choose that color. Unfortunately, a lot of them look more like clown bursts with WAYYYY too much red and not a smooth enough transition.
I was going to bring this up, but in a positive light.
If you look at pictures of vintage Les Pauls when they were new, most (if not all) of them look like that. However the awesome, vintage, divine dye they were using to finish the guitars back in fiddy nine was ultra-violet sensitive (aka sunlight makes it fade) and over the years and gigs and smoke and such, they turned into what we now call honeyburst and lemonburst and light burst and unburst etc. However the plethora of names, these are all modern inventions, they're basically like prefaded jeans. Just like every acid wash, light blue, pre-tattered pair of jeans was based on a super dark Levis 501...every "mojo"-flled, chipped, buckle rashed, Lemonburst R9 was based on a clownburst. (sorry, denim is the other thing I nerd out on besides guitars, so if that analogy was confusing just ignore it)
EDIT: Just did some research to check my facts, and they produced Tobacco Burst as well, same fading properties applied.
if anyone is a massive Les Paul nerd like myself, this page is full of wonderful little goodies that only the nerdiest of the nerdy will care about. If you read about how the finishing process changed through Gibsons "golden years" (58-60) and how they turned into the finishes that are really common today.
http://home.provide.net/~cfh/lpsun.html
I wish they would make an R9 with a really gaudy clownburst that would fade over time, but that will never happen, so given the options I think my favorite finish is a good example of a slight aged heritage cherry, not too washed out and not too clowny.